In her article, "Bring back shushing librarians," Laura Miller makes an argument that libraries should prioritize peace and quiet within their walls. She cites a Pew Research Center study that found 76% of those polled ranked “Quiet study spaces for adults and children” as "very important." Quiet space was ranked more important than special programs for children, job-search resources, access to subscription databases, and spaces for public meetings.
Libraries are currently trying to shed their reputations as silent sanctuaries. The libraries of today want to be seen as bustling community centers. They're prioritizing buzz at the expense of peace.
Commenters to the article propose designating specific quiet areas that are separate from the general areas. This appears to be the best compromise to accommodate both the patrons' needs and the library's vision.
My public library has a designated quiet reading room that's blocked off with glass walls. However, it's furnished with long wooden tables and stiff backed chairs, so it's not comfortable to stay in for long periods of time. Does your library have a quiet space?
We do have a quiet space and we strictly enforce it. Our library is mostly quiet except when school lets out. Then the teens and the tutors take over but it is only from about 3-5.
ReplyDeleteI am usually pretty accustomed to a louder noise level but my desk is right on the floor so I find that if I am getting annoyed the noise, it is probably WAY too loud!
The other time I get a little frustrated by the noise in the library is when people are clearly working or studying on our computers (which are directly in front of the circulation desk). I can hear that the staff members are talking to each other and being too loud and disruptive.
There has to be a general understanding on when to have a more appropriate talking level. If the library is quiet and you can see people studying, should you be raising your voice to shout across the library?